Friday, March 24, 2006

CHECK THIS OUT

SHNATEJAS

I have a plan for a year long program. I don't mean to take the wind out of the current Shnat plan being developed -- it's great that people are making strides from all different directions simultaneously. These different streams of creation will surely entangle and feed off each other in the very near future.

That said, the program that I have conceived has developed from the same basic considerations with a different solution. I went on Mifgash three years ago and was inspired by the energetic movement towards urban kibbutzim. The Shomrim on the trip came from different backgrounds and interests but by the end we were really on the same page and wanted more than anything to share our experiences. And as soon as there was a critical mass, we would definitely start communot. So far I think these are the basic goals of anyone who sees the communa movement as the next phase in hagshama.

My proposal is that we start a communa now in the U.S. Specifically, there is a communa now in Austin, TX that has a lot of momentum. The goals of the year program (codenamed ShnaTejas and pronounced ShnaTechas) are:

* Learn through experience what communa culture is like
* Refine the objectives/direction of the communa & movement
* Become active in the local community
* Refine/define reasons for living in a communa
* Be experienced in establishing and maintaining a communa financially, socially, and movement-wise for a full year. These duties include:
- Running peulot for one another
- Hosting weekly Shabbat dinners (Sha-Pot Lucks)
- Benefitting the local community through projects
- Maintaining a website and communication channels
- Sustaining ourselves financially (eventually through our projects)
- Establishing a non-profit org for the communa
* Developing a new leadership program for Hashomer Hatzair
* Living our hagshama today!

Just as Shomrim used to gather from all over North America in Liberty and learn to farm, learn to function communally, bond their kvutzot, and define their goals for several years before making aliya and establishing kibbutzim, so we need a platform to leap from. Some people are ready for Israel now, want to learn Hebrew, see themselves developing these skills in Israel, etc. That's great! I don't want to detract those people at all. However, there are advantages to starting a communa here:

1) First of all, there are social factors in our favor here. We all speak what passes for English, we have bank accounts, we have cars and stuff, we can lease houses and get jobs. I don't think those are the challenges the communa needs to face now. Eventually, if a kvutza/communa makes aliya together, they will face these issues and all the other challenges associated with establishing in a new country.

2) Living in one place for a period of a year or more is the best way to develop kvutza and experience living as a communa. Having spurts of time in different places, never having steady jobs or long-standing communa activities, working on projects temporarily and then moving back to the U.S. -- this is more of a seminar-style program. This program will have a stronger communa-living component.

3) We are close to home and family. Some people will find Israel difficult for security and other reasons. JetBlue flies directly from Austin to NYC for $79 each way (flights elsewhere are cheap as well). We will be active in HHNA throughout the year, host seminars, and start a ken.

4) We are financially independent. Rather than saving up money now, waiting on a long line for hand-outs from the Israeli govt, or potentially compromising the integrity of the program because of funding issues, the Austin Communa is financially independent and will only become more so as the number of members grows. Currently, Bina is a full-time substitute teacher and I am a full-time student while tutoring and teaching piano part-time. We could potentially earn enough next year to pay down serious student loans, etc. (You might also consider transfering to UT or ACC for the year and keep studying.)

5) Austin is the liberal capital of the American South and one of the most liberal cities in NA. It is rife with social opportunities, projects, co-ops, support networks, etc. There is no way to summarize this point briefly, so I will just say that many excellent opportunities are right in front of us both figuratively and physically. We live in Central Austin by everything, in a house in a magical neighborhood with year-round beautiful weather.

Those are some of the benefits of staying in the U.S. I don't propose to abandon the Zionist dream. On the contrary, I believe that by establishing communa, we will have the resources, experience, and tight kvutzot that are the basic elements necessary for meaningful aliya. There are many angles to look at this issue. For example, only this program leaves the option to stay longer than a year. Funds are limited enough for the Israel Shnat program, plus after a year you will be exposed to the military draft. The Austin Communa is a project that can accept new members and continue to grow year after year, creating facts on the ground (tachles)!

The other important element that is unique about this idea is the Hashomer leadership program built in. As a movement, we are starting to adopt the Israeli model of having madrichim for kvutzot at all stages, even when they are in hadracha. However, we don't offer a real hadracha training program. Thus, a program will be developed to train throughout the year. Everyone will be responsible for planning peulot for the communa on a rotating basis. Plus, there will be a rotating position of madrich communa for 1-2 months who will also be responsible for planning a weekly peula in addition, plus plan an educational seminar for the communa and guests, etc. This program will be elaborated in the future.

There are pros and cons with every plan. I am aiming to draw people who want to establish communot now and help them spread in NA. Personally, I'm somewhat disillusioned that after three years of going on Mifgash what we've produced is a new seminar in Israel and one communa (ours). Bina and I are committed to Austin for the next few years for our own reasons and work our asses off, but we're still working towards communa and growing it slowly but steadily every day.

Our feature outreach project at the moment is our weekly Shabbat dinners: http://www.shapotluck.com/ . Soon we should have a website for the communa and we will start organizing our core group of people towards activation in the community.

I will stop now and let the conversation develop (hopefully). It's not all thought out, which is fine because it should be jointly developed by all the people who are interested.

Chazak & Ematz!
Omri

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Thanks Dave, I think we really have the same idea in mind. I have both conflicting thoughts as well: the importance of Israel is clear, but wouldn't it be amazing to have a network of communot everywhere (isn't there work to be done everywhere)?

I'm not sure where the development of communot will eventually lead, but that's up for people later on to decide. For now, I think that focusing on communot here is very important because you can't just throw random people together, have them share, and find a random project and call that a communa. What is a communa, then? I'm not sure, but I know that it's a lot more cohesive and takes time to develop its personality, goals, and activities. (None of this is a response or critique of the Israel Shnat program at all. It's a separate discussion.)

Within my means and schedule and personal goals, Israel is not right for me now. I also don't have a kvutza to move with to Israel. I mean, I do. But we're not living together and we're not building communa -- what I see as prerequisites to moving to Israel. The time for experimentation is now. There's no reason to not have lots of communot, or at least a few with many more people, right now. And the place for experimentation, in my opinion, is here, before we have the added challenges of Israel. --- BUT that's what's right for me in my life now. This isn't about picking which direction is the best but just expanding options. There might be other people who are in a similar position to me or cannot go to Israel for other reasons.

I also think there are advantages to being here, which I listed in my original proposal. The biggest that I see is permanence. The Austin Communa will keep on running for the next few years even if no one else joins us (except Mike Rubinov who's coming in a few months). The reason I call the Israel Shnat program a 'seminar' is because you go, travel around, learn things, do what you're going to do, and then come home. I don't think we're/I'm ready to lay down roots in Israel. Having some communot with year-round activities that are stable is very important to our movement right now.

All this said, I'm really excited for the people to do Shnat Israel and for our paths to converge again soon. I think there are gonna be awesome experiences that are not built into my plan. I also hope that if ShnaTejas gains momentum that more official attention will be given to it and then we'll be able to coordinate awesome plans and projects and seminars on the level that is being discussed here for Isreal next year.

Final thought: please only comment about this program on this thread. To gain momentum, we don't need everyone's participation, but we need a forum that's focused on this topic. And I think my original post got drowned in other posts, so please be mindful of that.

Chazak!

Anonymous said...

OG I think this is a very interesting and good idea whether for this group of people to consider or others I want to talk to you more about it

Adam (Shlomo)